So the other day I was watching Oprah for some reason, and they were discussing sex in long-term relationships. One of the main focuses of the show was one couple in particular, who hadn’t had sex for twelve years. No, they weren’t monks, no neither of them had AIDS. Basically it was just a passive, semi-intentional effort on the part of the wife, who openly claimed she wasn’t really attracted to the husband on a physical level anymore, and admitted she could go the rest of her life without sex and not feel any feelings of lust. What’s most perplexing about all this is the husband took all of this in stride, even though he acknowledged how difficult this has been for him.
I’m starting to think that it’s only pussies like this that are capable of continued appreciation towards My Bloody Valentine.
For me a long relationship really holds little to no pros, other then the fact that you are entitled to constant sexual activities from the other person, but even that assumption has been debunked by countless studies that shows us sex dwindles relentlessly in nearly all marriages, maybe not to the point of a twelve year hiatus, but it does become the exception and not the rule, this much is pretty much a constant (just one more piece of evidence that supports my theory that people aren’t inherently designed for such commitments). Having said that, it’d be unfathomable for me to go a month within a marriage without sex, but twelve years? There’s patience, and then there’s just being a spineless wimp, and I think you’re crossing that line right around the two months periods without sex and sans immediate, drastic action.
It goes without a doubt that this piece of shit is a worthless loser, willing to suppress a basic human right in the name of complacency, but there’s a bigger issue here. What is the statute of limitations on the impact of one monumentally great event before we’re entitled to something more? It’s hard to put a number on it, but for the sake of this piece, let’s settle on seventeen.
Seventeen years. That’s the time between My Bloody Valentine’s seminal ‘Loveless’ album and the current day. During that period, we saw Kevin Shields (who does represent another one of those “one man projects”, much like Robert Pollard is Guided By Voices and Trent Reznor is Nine Inch Nails, except these two guys still make music) contribute exactly one new song, and it wasn’t even really his song, just covering the Wire song ‘Map Ref. 41N 93W’ for a Wire tribute album. It wasn’t that great of a cover, just adding a lot of fuzziness to the original, but truth be told, I really wouldn’t care how good it was, considering you know, it’s just one cover song.
In this extended hiatus (and I’m using that term in the loosest sense possible), this is the only new music released from the band. So how did Shields keep busy you ask? Don’t bother, it’s just a bunch of meaningless stuff that really amounts to nothing other then helping his name stay around. Specifically he played guitar sparingly for Primal Scream, contributed some score material to the Sofia Coppola movie Lost In Translation, and lastly (and probably least importantly), co-produced an entirely forgettable Dinosaur Jr. album.
Skip ahead to the present day, and that analysis requires no updating, no alterations. That pathetic examination of extreme inactivity is still accurate, yet now they are STILL being talked about, simply because a) they played a handful of prestigious reunion shows, namely headlining Coachella, Roskilde, and All Tomorrow’s Parties, playing, you guessed it, ‘Loveless’ in its entirety, and b) there are some reports on a follow-up being in the band’s near future, but if ‘Chinese Democracy’ has taught us anything… well more on that later.
For the record, Shields has spoken on his behalf, trying to justify the lull of most epic proportions.
“Too often when people make good records, there’s an aftershock effect, and they collapse psychologically and emotionally. Brian Wilson is a classic case of that. I’m trying to prove that you can make genuinely interesting music and come out with new ideas without an emotional drain to the point where you break down. I could make another record that would top the others we’ve made - I’ve been ready to for a while now - but to me it’s extremely important to make that record in such a way that I’ll be able to make another one. For lots of small, petty human reasons I won’t go into, I’d like to be around in five years time, making better and better records”.
Yeah, pretty sure that quote lost all credibility at the millennial mark. Now we’re left with no choice but to group the group in with the drama associated with ‘Chinese Democracy’, but hey, even that homophobic snotrag finally got his shit together and we are faced with the terrifying concept of a new Guns n’ Roses album, which leaves the follow-up to ‘Loveless’ without equal in terms of absurdity in the name of unacceptable prolonged absences.
What makes all of this even more frustrating, is many consider ‘Loveless’ the best album of the nineties. Not me, sonically it was obviously very groundbreaking, but I could never hold something which is essentially a “mood album” among the very best of that great decade. Having said that, I’m not here to debate the merits of ‘Loveless’, it’s obviously a pretty tremendous record if it has carried the band this far without any further contributions from the band, but I am going to do what I’ve seen really nobody else do, and that’s hold Mr. Shields totally and utterly accountable for nearly two decades of indolence. Hell, I could have written this after the first ten years but what the fuck, I gave him another eight years grace. Enough is enough though, seriously.
Shields says to him, making great music is about capturing a moment when you feel inspired, and making music around that flash of profound insight. Fair enough, but you mean to tell me you haven’t been inspired in seventeen years? That tells me you’re in the wrong business. Maybe you should be working for the US.Postal Service or something. I’m starting to think Shields has more in common with Bukowski’s alter ego Harry Chinaski then Brian Wilson. At least Chinaski put his apathy to use and serviced the community through mail organization/deliveries. Shields just took enough space, not a ton, but intentionally just enough to be discussed and revered. It actually pisses me off I even have to write about someone so absurdly irrelevant in terms of the recent music scene, especially because I think I’m probably doing him a favour by getting this published.
Recently, Shields has claimed the band is working on new material, and also stated that the material he recorded in 1996/97 is actually a lot better then he remembered it being. What all this translates into, is he’s just digging up old stuff for inclusion on a new MBV studio release, and what that translates into, is Shields is still plumb-fuck out of ideas. That’s his right, there’s a lot of bands that have released one great record then faded into obscurity, but there’s the tricky part, somewhere between where Shields is at and oblivion where all those other one-trick ponies now reside. If he doesn’t want to do shit all with his musical career and rest on the laurels of ‘Loveless’, I really don’t care, and am still grateful for his one contribution that we are still feeling the effects of today.
However, the current importance of My Bloody Valentine is marginal at best, and I just wish he could do us a single favour for once, and just give his fans some of that indifference he seems have no shortage of. Maybe then his fans will finally stop caring, and give the band what they truly deserve.
Ha
I can tell how much you must hate them purely on the amount of swearing I had to remove to make this (fairly) suitable for a family audience. Well written as ever, I only hope we never fall out!
Someone clearly needs to get laid with all that sex on the brain.
MBV are/were a great band and have influenced directly countless other great bands.
Just because their music doesn’t have a singalong ‘woah woah’ chorus does not make it shite.
Oooh, now I’ve actually read it all the way through (I got massively bored halfway through the third paragraph the first time I tried), I get your point (I think).
He should make another record. Or he should have made one years ago? I’m not sure.
I don’t agree anyway, I’m dead glad the Stone Roses didn’t try and make another album, sometimes bands should just quit after making an undoubted classic rather than carrying on peddling second-rate nonsense. Maybe Shields is quite happy spending his days mowing the lawn and doing Su-do-ku.
I would be.
Janie,
It’d be one thing if Shields said, “You know what, consider me retired until further notice”. But he never said this, or anything similar to this, instead he has been consistently talking about making new music, which obviously has never happened.
I respect his right to retire from music (until their followup gets released, that’s how I will regard the current state of MBV), but as fans, we gotta hold him accountable for nearly two decades of inactivity.
I’m not sure you have your facts straight, because for years now, Shields has been teasing us with new updates in terms of the followup album only to give us nothing. He never said he quit, which means we can’t let him off the hook.
As for the Stone Roses, I’ll never fully understand the U.K’s obsession with them, but if my information is correct, their debut was the one you referred to as an ‘undoubted classic’, and they did give us a second album: Second Coming, which was an unredeemable piece of garbage.
As fans, we have to hold these bands accountable. If we don’t, who will?
I kinda see where you’re coming from but I don’t really see what we have to hold them accountable for? There’s no contract between fans and bands saying how regularly they need to release albums. I couldn’t care any less that it’s been 17 years since Loveless, it’s still a fantastic album so why shouldn’t people still regard it as such? Shields is the musician, it’s up to him and the rest of the band when they want to put something new out. What’s the problem with having second thoughts about your material? When it’s following an album with the status of Loveless, whether it’s 17 years, 2 years, a week or half a century later, it’s always going to compared to it and the band probably feel they want to try to top, or at least equal it, as best they can.
I don’t believe bands should be held accountable to any one but themselves for anything they do or don’t release. They rarely exist to provide us with endless production lines of music, especially the MBV types, they exist for themselves. If somebody else likes what they do, great, but ultimately they are the only people they need to make happy. Complaining about their albums taking too long just seems a bit petulant to me.
Granted I haven’t been alive long enough to have known what Shields has been saying over the years (I was 5 the year Loveless was released and only discovered them at about 18) and so may be more inclined to agree had I lived through it but I really don’t think he owes us anything. Saying “consider me retired until further notice” is just daft, by that logic all bands not recording an album right this very minute or playing a gig right now should consider themselves retired until further notice too, no?
As for the comment about the shows ATP put on, of course they were going to play Loveless all the way through. A band isn’t going to come back after that long and play all their shit songs, a band isn’t ever going to play their weaker songs live and considering Isn’t Anything was pretty average that kinda narrows it down a bit.
For the record, the gigs (certainly the one I went to at The Roundhouse anyway) were ear-drum-smashingly fantastic
Still a great band. Saw them at the Roundhouse and they kicked ass. Met many of their fans and they were nice doods, no sings of extreme adulation.
As for ‘Loveless’; the album is seminal and ‘Isn’t Anything’ isn’t much less. For all the band has made, their complacency is actually very comforting and reassuring. Not everyone is a Morrissey.
I love this band and in a way I’m glad they haven’t made anymore records; at least they’ve given us their best sparing us with their worst. But yeah, i liked your insight Jeff.